TUC letter - Time off for public duties

Author
Peter Wieltschnig
Policy Lead - Employment Rights & Labour Markets
Report type
Letter
Issue date

Dear colleagues,

Time off for public duties

The Trades Union Congress (TUC) is the voice of Britain at work. We represent more than 5.3 million working people in 47 unions across the economy. We support unions to grow and thrive, and we stand up for everyone who works for a living.

The TUC welcomes the opportunity to respond to the Government's consultation on reforming the statutory entitlement to time off for public duties under section 50 of the Employment Rights Act 1996.

The TUC strongly supports the principle underpinning these rights. That is, that working people should be able to participate in public life and contribute to the governance and delivery of public services without being forced to choose between civic service and their employment. The right to reasonable time off for public duties has historically been an important means of ensuring that public institutions are not dominated by those with independent wealth, flexible professional careers, or other advantages that make participation easier. The consultation recognises that the original purpose of the entitlement was to enable working people to participate in civic life and that representative public institutions require participation from people with a range of backgrounds.

Trade unions believe it is vital that social mobility and equal access to civic participation must remain at the heart of any reform. Public offices and appointments should be accessible to workers in all occupations, sectors and income groups. People bring valuable lived experience from their workplaces and communities, whether they serve as a magistrate, school governor, councillor, member of a public board or holder of another public office. Public institutions are stronger when they include the voices of working people, including those on low incomes, in insecure work, or from groups that have traditionally been underrepresented in formal positions of authority. 2

The TUC therefore supports measures that extend entitlement to additional roles where this would widen participation and strengthen public services. We agree that legislation should be kept under review to ensure that it reflects current and developing public service structures and continues to support civic engagement.

However, the TUC does not support the removal of any existing category of public duty from the scope of the entitlement where that duty continues to exist and perform a meaningful public function. We are particularly concerned by the proposal that individuals carrying out public duties for national public sector organisations should no longer be entitled to statutory time off.

The distinction between local and national public duties is not a sound basis for determining access to statutory support. National public bodies make decisions that shape the delivery of services, regulate important sectors and influence policy outcomes that affect working people across the country. There is a strong public interest in ensuring that these bodies draw on a broad range of perspectives and experiences, including those of ordinary workers. There is strong evidence that more diverse boards make better decisions. 1 As the Options Paper recognises, ‘[i]ncreased equality of opportunity to civic roles contributes to more representative public bodies and offices. The inclusion of these individuals can bring additional and novel knowledge and expertise, supporting the more effective fulfilment of various statutory functions.’

While we recognise that practice has changed over recent decades towards national public body officers holding more senior professional occupations, such practice should not be treated as static. Nor should it be assumed that increasing greater formal professionalisation means that practice should remain less inclusive to those without independent wealth or flexible professional careers that allow them to take on these roles. The inclusion of national public body roles in the statutory duty allows for practice to change to encourage greater diversity and inclusion. Such developments should not be stymied by the removal of such roles from the list of roles. If a national public body was to start a drive to recruit from more diverse and less advantaged backgrounds, something that the TUC would encourage, lack of access to time off work, may again arise as a constraining factor from those who would otherwise participate.

Removing entitlement from these roles risks creating a two-tier system of public participation. Individuals in senior professional occupations, with higher incomes or greater flexibility over their working arrangements, will often continue to be able to undertake such duties. By contrast, workers in lower-paid jobs, shift-based roles, customer-facing occupations, manufacturing, transport, retail, social care and other sectors may find participation impossible without statutory protection. The practical effect would be to narrow the social base from which public bodies recruit their members.

The TUC is concerned that this would undermine social mobility. Public duties often provide important opportunities for skills development, leadership experience, governance expertise and civic engagement. Participation can also help workers build their skillsets and advance to their career progression opportunities. If access to these opportunities becomes increasingly dependent on financial resources or occupational privilege, existing inequalities are likely to be reinforced. 3

We also believe that representative public institutions require representation not only from different geographic areas but from different socioeconomic backgrounds. Working people should be present wherever public decisions are made, whether at local, regional or national level. The objective should be to broaden participation, not narrow it.

For these reasons, the TUC urges the government to adopt an approach that expands opportunities for civic participation and protects existing rights. We support extending eligibility, but we do not support removing entitlement from any current category of public duty that remains active and relevant. Reform should be guided by the principle that participation in public life should be accessible to workers from all backgrounds and all parts of the labour market. Strengthening, rather than restricting, access to time off for public duties is the best way to ensure that public institutions remain representative, inclusive and reflective of the people they serve.

Yours sincerely,

Peter Wieltschnig
Policy lead, employment rights & labour markets
Policy & Analysis Department

Enable Two-Factor Authentication

To access the admin area, you will need to setup two-factor authentication (TFA).

Setup now