date: 14 November 2011
embargo: 00.01hrs Tuesday 15 November 2011
Remuneration reports drew the greatest opposition from institutional investors yet bank remuneration reports were widely supported, according to the latest TUC fund manager voting survey published today (Tuesday).
The ninth annual fund manager fund voting survey, published to coincide with the TUC Pension Trustee Conference taking place in central London today, analyses the voting records of more than 20 fund managers, pension funds and voting agencies across 69 company resolutions between January and December 2010.
The survey has again found a sharp divide in voting stances, with four respondents supporting more than 70 per cent of resolutions, while five respondents supported less than a third.
Remuneration was the most common topic of engagement and the issue over which respondents were most likely to oppose company management. Half of the survey respondents supported less than half the remuneration reports on which votes were sought, and many supported less than a third.
The remuneration reports of all five major UK-listed banks were included in this year's survey. Surprisingly, bank remuneration reports comprised three of the five reports with the highest level of support in the survey. Barclays' remuneration report was backed by 75 per cent of all respondents - the highest in the survey.
These findings are surprising given the banks' recent stock market performance and dividend returns, says the TUC.
This year's survey showed further progress in the disclosure of voting records, with 13 respondents disclosing a full voting record, compared to just nine last year. However, the quality of information varied, with several fund managers only disclosing votes against and abstentions, and others only providing headline statistics.
This improvement in voting disclosure is good news for pension trustees and pension scheme members as it helps them to see how fund managers are using their shareholder mandate to influence companies, says the TUC.
Several respondents indentified changes made as a result of the introduction of the Stewardship Code a year ago, such as improved engagement record keeping. However, the Code has had very little effect on the voting stances taken by institutional investors and needs to be toughened up, says the TUC.
TUC General Secretary Brendan Barber said: 'Shareholders are supposed to be the ultimate check on our corporate system, but too many fund managers are still failing to use the power of their investments to influence corporate behaviour.
'The fact that UK bank remuneration reports received so much backing in the face of diminishing dividends and poor stock market performance is a clear sign that institutional investors are not doing their job properly.
'Reform of our corporate culture is long overdue and ministers need to take the lead in forcing through change, particularly on executive pay, where remuneration committees are frequently failing to act in a transparent and responsible manner.'
NOTES TO EDITORS:
- The 2011 fund manager voting survey is available from http://www.tuc.org.uk/tucfiles/137/Fund_Manager_Voting_Survey_2011.pdfÂ
- The policies and process section of the survey this year looks at policies on stock lending, engagement on labour issues, the impact of the stewardship code, the UN Principles of Responsible Investment (UNPRI) and resources devoted to corporate governance and responsibility.
- Speakers at the TUC Pensions Trustee Conference include Pensions Minister Steve Webb, Dr. Paul Woolley from the London School of Economics and TUC Assistant General Secretary Kay Carberry. The conference takes place at Congress House, 23-28 Great Russell Street, London WC1B 3LS between 9.30am and 4.30pm. To apply for media accreditation contact Jennifer Mann on 020 7467 1222 or email [email protected]
- Twenty two investment organisations took part in this year's survey, the same as last year.
- The TUC supports a network of 1,000 trade union trustees. It provides newsletters, events, briefings and training for members of the network and acts as a point of contact and advice for union trustees.
- All TUC press releases can be found at www.tuc.org.uk
Liz Chinchen T: 020 7467 1248 M: 07778 158175 E: [email protected]
Rob Holdsworth T: 020 7467 1372 M: 07717 531150 E: [email protected]
Elly Gibson T: 020 7467 1337 M: 07900 910624 E: [email protected]
Issued: 15 November, 2011